What Are Fitness Trackers and How Do They Work?
A fitness tracker is a wearable device or app that uses sensors to estimate your activity. Motion sensors count steps, a light-based sensor reads your pulse, and GPS measures distance; software turns those signals into estimates of sleep and calories. Steps and heart rate are fairly accurate; calorie counts are much less so.
Fitness trackers work by measuring signals from your body and movement, then running them through software that estimates things like steps, distance, heart rate, sleep and calories burned. Some of those numbers are close measurements; others are educated guesses. Knowing which is which helps you get real value from a tracker without being misled by it. Here is how the sensors work, what research says about their accuracy, and how to use one well.
What is a fitness tracker?
A fitness tracker is any device or app that records your physical activity. The main types are:
- Wrist bands: slim, simple devices focused on steps, heart rate and sleep, often with long battery life.
- Smartwatches: wrist computers that add activity tracking to messages, apps and, often, built-in GPS.
- Clip-on pedometers: small step counters worn on a waistband or belt. Basic models only count steps.
- Phone apps: most smartphones have motion sensors built in, so a free app can count steps while the phone is in your pocket.
- Smart rings: worn on a finger, usually focused on sleep, heart rate and daily activity.
They all rely on a similar set of sensors, described below.
How fitness trackers count steps: accelerometers
The core sensor is an accelerometer, a tiny chip that measures changes in speed and direction of movement. Every step produces a small, repeating jolt. The tracker’s software looks for that rhythmic pattern and counts each cycle as a step, while trying to ignore movements that don’t fit, such as a bumpy car ride. Many devices also include a gyroscope, which senses rotation and helps the software tell one kind of movement from another.
Without GPS, a tracker estimates distance by multiplying your steps by an estimated stride length, usually calculated from the height you enter. That is why distance can be off if your stride is unusually long or short; many devices let you set your stride length or calibrate it on a measured walk. For how step counts relate to health, see how many steps you should walk a day.
How optical heart-rate sensors work
The lights on the back of a watch or band are an optical heart-rate sensor. The method is called photoplethysmography (PPG), which a study by Bent and colleagues in npj Digital Medicine describes as an optical method for measuring changes in blood volume under the skin. Small LEDs, usually green, shine light into your skin, and a sensor measures how much light comes back. Blood absorbs light, and the amount of blood under the sensor rises and falls with each heartbeat, so the reflected light pulses in time with your pulse. Software turns those pulses into a heart rate.
The same study, which tested devices on 53 people, found that error during activity was on average 30% higher than at rest. Two reasons it gives: the sensor shifting on the skin as you move, and “signal crossover,” where the sensor locks onto the rhythm of repetitive movement, such as arm swing while walking, instead of your heartbeat. A snug fit just above the wrist bone helps.
Skin tone has been a concern because the method relies on light. The Bent study found no statistically significant difference in accuracy across skin tones, while the Stanford study described below reported higher error for darker skin tones, so the question is not fully settled.
GPS, altimeters and other sensors
- GPS uses signals from satellites to track your position. By comparing positions over time, the device calculates distance, pace and route for walks, runs and rides. It works best outdoors with a clear view of the sky and is less reliable among tall buildings or under heavy tree cover. Devices without their own GPS can often borrow your phone’s.
- Barometric altimeters sense small changes in air pressure, which drops as you go up. A climb of roughly one story, combined with steps, is counted as a floor.
- Other sensors on some devices include skin temperature sensors and electrodes for an on-demand heart rhythm reading. Readings that suggest a health problem are a reason to talk with a doctor, not a diagnosis.
How trackers estimate sleep and calories
Sleep
Trackers don’t measure sleep directly. They infer it from how little you move and, in newer devices, from heart rate and related signals. A review by de Zambotti and colleagues in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise found that wearables detect sleep well, with sensitivity above 90%, but are worse at detecting time awake, because people can lie still without sleeping. The result is that trackers tend to overestimate total sleep, and their sleep-stage estimates are less reliable. The authors concluded the devices are not a stand-alone tool for diagnosing sleep disorders.
Calories
To estimate calories burned (energy expenditure), a tracker combines your movement and heart rate with the age, sex, height and weight you enter, then applies the manufacturer’s formula. Each of those inputs carries error, and the formulas are not public, which helps explain why calorie numbers are the least accurate figures on the screen.
How accurate are fitness trackers?
Two well-known pieces of research give a good picture.
The Stanford wrist-device study. Shcherbina and colleagues at Stanford, writing in the Journal of Personalized Medicine, tested seven wrist-worn devices on 60 adults of varied age, size, skin tone and fitness while they sat, walked, ran and cycled, comparing them with lab equipment. Heart rate was generally good: the best device had a median error of 2% and the worst 6.8%. Energy expenditure was poor: no device had an error below 20%, and median errors ranged from 27.4% to 92.6%.
- 2–6.8%median heart-rate error across seven wrist devices (Stanford study)
- 27–93%median calorie-estimate error across the same devices
- 158publications in a systematic review of wearable accuracy
A large systematic review. Fuller and colleagues reviewed 158 publications covering nine brands, in JMIR mHealth and uHealth. They concluded that the devices are accurate for steps and heart rate in laboratory settings, but that this varies by manufacturer and device, and that no brand was accurate for energy expenditure. In everyday (free-living) conditions, only 42% of step-count comparisons were within 10% of the reference measure, with a slight tendency to overcount.
How to choose a fitness tracker
Start with what you actually want to know, then pick the simplest device that does it:
| If you want to | Look for | Simplest option |
|---|---|---|
| Count daily steps | An accelerometer; any tracker has one | A phone app or clip-on pedometer |
| Check workout intensity | Optical heart-rate sensor | A band or watch with heart rate |
| Map walks, runs or rides | Built-in GPS, or phone GPS | A phone app carried with you |
| Count floors climbed | Barometric altimeter | A band or watch that lists floors |
| Track sleep patterns | A comfortable device you can wear overnight | A band or ring |
Also consider comfort, battery life, water resistance if you swim, a screen you can read easily, and whether the app works with your phone. If you will only look at your step count, a basic, inexpensive option is enough.
How to use a fitness tracker well
- Watch trends, not single numbers. Any one reading can be off, so compare your own weekly averages on the same device over time, such as this week against last month.
- Enter accurate details. Height, weight and age feed into stride length and calorie estimates.
- Wear it the same way each day, on the same wrist and snug enough for the heart-rate sensor.
- Don’t eat back exercise calories based on the tracker’s estimate; it is the least reliable number.
- Set goals that build gradually, such as a few hundred more steps a day than your usual.
For ways to log activity with or without a device, see how to track daily physical activity.
Fitness trackers and privacy
Trackers collect personal data: your location, heart rate, sleep and daily routine. The Federal Trade Commission warns that some health apps may share or even sell users’ data and that, unlike your doctor, these apps may not be covered by health privacy laws such as HIPAA. Its advice:
- Read the privacy notice to see what is collected and who it is shared with.
- Check the app’s settings, since defaults often favor sharing, and choose more protective options.
- Keep the app and device updated, since updates often fix security problems.
- Consider turning off public sharing of routes, which can reveal where you live and when you are out.
You don’t need a tracker to be active
A tracker is a tool, not a requirement. The physical activity guidelines are written in minutes, which you can time with any clock, and you can judge intensity with the talk test explained in what counts as moderate physical activity. If a device motivates you, use it; if the numbers make you anxious, put it away and keep moving.
Common mistakes with fitness trackers
- Treating calorie counts as exact. Research finds energy expenditure is the least accurate measure. Use it, at most, as a rough guide.
- Chasing a perfect step number. A trend that rises over weeks matters more than hitting an exact daily figure.
- Ignoring how it feels. Your own sense of effort is a valid guide to intensity, especially when the heart-rate reading looks odd.
- Accepting default sharing settings. Review what the app collects and shares, and turn off what you don’t need.
Frequently asked questions
How do fitness trackers count steps?
An accelerometer inside the device senses the repeating jolt of each step, and software counts those rhythmic patterns as steps while trying to ignore other movement.
How accurate are fitness trackers for calories burned?
Not very. In a Stanford study of seven wrist-worn devices published in the Journal of Personalized Medicine, no device estimated energy expenditure within 20%, and a review of 158 studies found no brand was accurate for it.
How does a smartwatch measure heart rate?
It shines light, usually green, into the skin and measures how much is reflected back. Because blood absorbs light and blood volume changes with each heartbeat, the reflected light pulses with your heart rate.
Are fitness trackers accurate for sleep?
They are good at detecting sleep but weaker at detecting time awake, so they tend to overestimate total sleep. They cannot diagnose sleep disorders.
Is a phone as good as a fitness tracker for steps?
Phones contain the same kind of motion sensor and can count steps well, but only while you carry the phone. A wrist or clip-on device catches steps taken when the phone is set down.
References
- Accuracy in Wrist-Worn, Sensor-Based Measurements of Heart Rate and Energy Expenditure in a Diverse Cohort (Journal of Personalized Medicine, PMC)
- Reliability and Validity of Commercially Available Wearable Devices for Measuring Steps, Energy Expenditure, and Heart Rate: Systematic Review (JMIR mHealth and uHealth, PMC)
- Investigating Sources of Inaccuracy in Wearable Optical Heart Rate Sensors (npj Digital Medicine, PMC)
- Wearable Sleep Technology in Clinical and Research Settings (Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, PMC)
- Does Your Health App Protect Your Sensitive Info? (Federal Trade Commission)